Why most companies enter Asia in the wrong order
Start with the Asian market where you can learn fastest and cheapest, not the biggest one. Sequence the rest by what each market teaches you about the next.
Most companies enter Asia in the order of ambition: the biggest market first, or a regional hub first, or wherever the founder has a contact. A better order starts with the market where you can learn fastest and most cheaply, then moves to the markets that first one teaches you about. Sequence by evidence, not by size.
The three orders that usually go wrong
I see the same patterns again and again with founders looking at Asia.
Biggest first. Mainland China and Japan are huge, so they look like the obvious prize. But large markets are often the slowest to read, the most competitive, and the most expensive to get wrong. If your first market is also your hardest, you can spend a year without learning whether the problem is your product, your price, your partner or the market itself.
Hub first. Some companies register in Hong Kong or Singapore, hire a regional head and sign a lease before they have a single Asian customer. A hub is useful, but it is an operating decision, not a market. Opening one first means paying fixed costs while you are still guessing.
Contact first. A founder knows a distributor in Taipei or a former colleague in Tokyo, so that becomes the first market. A warm introduction is valuable, but it is a reason to test a market, not proof that the market fits.
Underneath all three is the same mistake: treating Asia as one market, or treating a new market as a translation exercise. It is neither. Each market has its own buyers, decision habits, regulation and competitors, and the order you take them in shapes what you learn.
What a good order looks like
A good sequence answers four questions for each candidate market:
- Fit. Is there a clear customer with an urgent problem your product solves here, and will they pay?
- Speed of learning. How quickly can you get real signals: meetings, pilots, paid orders?
- Cost of being wrong. If it does not work, how much time and money have you lost?
- Carry-over. What will success here teach you, or give you, for the next market? Language, references, partners, supply chain or regulatory approvals can all carry over.
The first market should score well on fit and speed, and low on cost of being wrong. Later markets should be chosen partly for carry-over.
A simple scoring table
Score each market you are considering from 1 (weak) to 5 (strong). For cost of being wrong, a high score means the cost is low.
| Market | Fit | Speed of learning | Cost of being wrong (5 = low) | Carry-over to next market | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Market A | |||||
| Market B | |||||
| Market C |
Fill it in with your team, and write one sentence of evidence next to every score. If a score has no evidence behind it, that is the first thing to test.
A worked example
Here is an illustrative example, not a real client. A European B2B software company is choosing between Japan, Taiwan and Hong Kong.
Japan has the largest buyer base for its product, but buying decisions involve many people and can take a long time, and the company has no Japanese-speaking staff. Taiwan has a smaller buyer base, faster access to decision-makers through an existing partner, and Mandarin-language materials that could later help in other Mandarin-speaking markets. Hong Kong is easy to operate in but has fewer buyers in this segment.
A "biggest first" order says Japan. An evidence-first order says: run a three-month pilot in Taiwan, use Hong Kong as the admin base if needed, and enter Japan once the company has local references, a clearer price point and budget for a Japanese-speaking hire. Japan is not dropped. It is moved to the point where the company can afford to learn there.
What this looks like in practice
When I advised a Mainland China knowledge business that wanted to go overseas, the instinct was to "go international" in one move. My advice was to set up an overseas company and then think market by market about Taiwan, Singapore and Malaysia: what each audience wanted, the local trends, and how content and distribution would need to be built differently for each. The sequence came from those differences, not from a map.
In our own startups, we opened regional offices in Mainland China, Taiwan and Japan from a Hong Kong base: Mainland China first, then Japan, then Taiwan. The lesson I keep returning to: move fast on evidence, not simply fast. Speed in the wrong direction only burns more money.
When to change the order
Your sequence is a plan, not a promise. Revisit it when:
- A pilot shows strong demand somewhere you ranked low.
- A partner or regulation changes the cost of entry in a market.
- Your first market stalls for two or three months with no clear reason.
Set the review date before you start, so the decision is made on evidence rather than hope.
What to do next
- List every Asian market you are considering and score each one with the table above, with one line of evidence per score.
- Separate your hub decision from your first-market decision, and make the market decision first.
- Design one low-cost test for your top-scoring market that would give you a clear signal within 90 days.
Government investment agencies such as InvestHK, JETRO, InvesTaiwan and the Singapore Economic Development Board publish starting information on setting up in their markets; their sites are linked below. This article is educational and not legal, tax or investment advice.
Quick answers
Should I enter the biggest Asian market first?
Usually not. The biggest market is often the slowest and most expensive place to learn, so most companies do better proving their model somewhere smaller and closer first.
How many Asian markets should I enter at once?
One, until you have repeatable sales there. A second market makes sense once you know what worked in the first and why.
Is a regional hub the same as a first market?
No. A hub is where you base people and admin; a first market is where you win customers. They can be the same city, but treat them as separate decisions.
Sources
- InvestHK, Government of the Hong Kong SAR
- JETRO: Invest in Japan
- InvesTaiwan, Ministry of Economic Affairs
- Singapore Economic Development Board
Rules and programmes change. Check the official source before you act.
Educational decision support, not legal, tax, immigration, investment or admissions advice.
